NEC PA322UHD Review

From ColorWiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Created page with " With the PA322, NEC enters the world of 4K displays with the quality that not only satisfy the professional photographer, the 4K capability brings the same wide color gamut, uni...")
m
Line 1: Line 1:
-
 
+
With the PA322, NEC enters the world of 4K displays with the quality that not only satisfy the professional photographer, the 4K capability brings the same wide color gamut, uniformity and longevity to the videographer also.  This is a big monitor, with a big color gamut, and all the features you need for professional color work.
-
With the PA322, NEC enters the world of 4K displays with the quality that not only satisfy the professional photographer, the 4K capability brings the same wide color gamut, uniformity and longevity to the videographer also.
+
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Line 13: Line 12:
NEC website:
NEC website:
-
http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop%20-monitors/pa301w-bk
+
http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop-monitors/pa322uhd-bk
CHROMiX:
CHROMiX:
-
https://www2.chromix.com/colorgear/shop/productdetail.cxsa?toolid=50145
+
https://www.chromix.com/ColorGear/Shop/productdetail.cxsa?toolid=50278
=Color gamut=
=Color gamut=
-
[[File:301gamut.png|right|600px|PA301 gamut compared to AdobeRGB]]
+
[[File:PA322gamut.png|right|600px|PA322 gamut compared to AdobeRGB]]
-
Besides its large physical size, the 301 has a wide gamut, capable of reproducing all the saturated colors of the AdobeRGB working space.  The NEC literature claims 98.2% coverage of the AdobeRGB gamut and my rough visual estimate would confirm that.  In fact, the 301W has a broader gamut in the Red / Magenta spectrum than AdobeRGB.   A rough estimate of the gamut volume of this display is about 1,300,000 cubic Lab values (Using ColorThink Pro.)
+
The 322 has a wide color gamut, capable of reproducing all the colors of the AdobeRGB working space.  The NEC literature claims 99.2% coverage of the AdobeRGB gamut and my rough visual estimate would confirm that.  It almost fully encompasses AdobeRGB, and the small section of the orange gamut that pokes out does not matter much. A rough estimate of the gamut volume of this display is about 1,280,000 cubic Lab values (Using ColorThink Pro.)
=Uniformity=
=Uniformity=
-
The uniformity across the screen was very good.  The average dE between various locations on the screen was about '''.77'''.  The worst uniformity issue I found on my demo unit was between the upper left corner and the lower right corner.  There, the very worst single color difference was a very light gray at '''2.74''' dE (2000).  If that's the worst it gets, then it's still really very uniform.  Numbers like this means that the display has very even color across the screen.  Most differences are less than the human eye can detect and the worst is barely seen by the human eye.  The NEC uniformity is corrected for at the factory using a technology they call ColorComp, and Digital Uniformity Correction.  What is unknown is the question of how well the uniformity holds up over time.  NEC has a four-year warrantee.
+
The uniformity across the screen was very good.  The average dE between various locations on the screen was about '''.77'''.  The worst uniformity issue I found on my demo unit was between the upper left corner and the lower right corner.  There, the very worst single color difference was a very light gray at '''2.91''' dE (2000).  If that's the worst it gets, then it's still really very uniform.  Numbers like this means that the display has very even color across the screen.  Most differences are less than the human eye can detect and the worst is barely seen by the human eye.  The NEC uniformity is corrected for at the factory using a technology they call ColorComp, and Digital Uniformity Correction.  What is unknown is the question of how well the uniformity holds up over time.  NEC has a four-year warrantee.
-
For more specifics on the uniformity of this model, see the [[NEC_PA301W_Review#Uniformity_map|uniformity illustration at the end of this article.]]
+
For more specifics on the uniformity of this model, see the [[NEC_PA322UHD_Review#Uniformity_map|uniformity illustration at the end of this article.]]
=Evenness=
=Evenness=
-
Visually the screen looks uniform, except for the last inch of screen space into the four corners and about 1/4 inch around the very edges of the display where the screen degrades to be slightly darker. This issue with the edges is normal for an LCD.
+
Visually the screen on the demo unit we tested looks uniform, except for 2 tiny areas.  There are some very slight irregularities in the smoothness of the display:  One small dot in the upper left corner, and another near the bottom of the screen, center, a collection of dots.  You have to learn to expect a few dead pixels on any display, even something as nice as this. But these don’t seem to be dead pixels since they are out of focus and only show up with the lighter colors.  These are also small enough to not cause problems for most users, but I point them out just the same.  These are most likely irregularities in the demo unit we were looking at.  I would not expect this to be visible in other units.
=Brightness=
=Brightness=
-
At maximum brightness the display was able to hit 347 cd/m<sup>2</sup>.    I ran it at 60 cd/m<sup>2</sup> without seeing any problems with shadow detail, banding, etc.  
+
At maximum brightness the display was able to hit 324 cd/m<sup>2</sup>.    I ran it at 60 cd/m<sup>2</sup> without seeing any problems with shadow detail, banding, etc.  
=Angle of view=
=Angle of view=
-
The official specs from NEC list viewing angles of 178<sup>ø</sup>,  vertical and horizontal.  In practice I see a slight reduction in brightness with the up-and-down variation than I do with the side-to-side variation.   This is such a large screen that a good viewing angle is essentialWhen your head is viewing the center of the screen, the corners are so far away that you really need good off-axis viewing angle just to be able to take in the whole screen in a uniform manner.  
+
The official specs from NEC list viewing angles of 178<sup>ø</sup>,  vertical and horizontal.  The larger a screen gets, the more important this viewing angle gets to be in your normal use of a monitor. This screen is so big that as you sit and look at different corners of the display, you're actually looking at the corners at widely different viewing anglesKeeping your perception consistent at all sections of the screen is critical. This is a feature that sets these professional-level monitors apart from the department store variety.  
=Internal Processing=
=Internal Processing=
Line 84: Line 83:
=Uniformity map=
=Uniformity map=
-
[[File:PA301W_uniformity.jpg|thumb|left|Click on image to display larger size]]
+
[[File:PA322 Uniformityx.png|thumb|left|Click on image to display larger size]]
<br clear="all"/>
<br clear="all"/>

Revision as of 20:01, 20 April 2016

With the PA322, NEC enters the world of 4K displays with the quality that not only satisfy the professional photographer, the 4K capability brings the same wide color gamut, uniformity and longevity to the videographer also. This is a big monitor, with a big color gamut, and all the features you need for professional color work.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX



The NEC PA301W

Links:

NEC website: http://www.necdisplay.com/p/desktop-monitors/pa322uhd-bk

CHROMiX: https://www.chromix.com/ColorGear/Shop/productdetail.cxsa?toolid=50278

Contents

Color gamut

PA322 gamut compared to AdobeRGB

The 322 has a wide color gamut, capable of reproducing all the colors of the AdobeRGB working space. The NEC literature claims 99.2% coverage of the AdobeRGB gamut and my rough visual estimate would confirm that. It almost fully encompasses AdobeRGB, and the small section of the orange gamut that pokes out does not matter much. A rough estimate of the gamut volume of this display is about 1,280,000 cubic Lab values (Using ColorThink Pro.)

Uniformity

The uniformity across the screen was very good. The average dE between various locations on the screen was about .77. The worst uniformity issue I found on my demo unit was between the upper left corner and the lower right corner. There, the very worst single color difference was a very light gray at 2.91 dE (2000). If that's the worst it gets, then it's still really very uniform. Numbers like this means that the display has very even color across the screen. Most differences are less than the human eye can detect and the worst is barely seen by the human eye. The NEC uniformity is corrected for at the factory using a technology they call ColorComp, and Digital Uniformity Correction. What is unknown is the question of how well the uniformity holds up over time. NEC has a four-year warrantee.

For more specifics on the uniformity of this model, see the uniformity illustration at the end of this article.

Evenness

Visually the screen on the demo unit we tested looks uniform, except for 2 tiny areas. There are some very slight irregularities in the smoothness of the display: One small dot in the upper left corner, and another near the bottom of the screen, center, a collection of dots. You have to learn to expect a few dead pixels on any display, even something as nice as this. But these don’t seem to be dead pixels since they are out of focus and only show up with the lighter colors. These are also small enough to not cause problems for most users, but I point them out just the same. These are most likely irregularities in the demo unit we were looking at. I would not expect this to be visible in other units.

Brightness

At maximum brightness the display was able to hit 324 cd/m2. I ran it at 60 cd/m2 without seeing any problems with shadow detail, banding, etc.

Angle of view

The official specs from NEC list viewing angles of 178ø, vertical and horizontal. The larger a screen gets, the more important this viewing angle gets to be in your normal use of a monitor. This screen is so big that as you sit and look at different corners of the display, you're actually looking at the corners at widely different viewing angles. Keeping your perception consistent at all sections of the screen is critical. This is a feature that sets these professional-level monitors apart from the department store variety.

Internal Processing

14-bit Internal processing.

Black Level

Much importance is place on an LCD monitor's ability to reproduce blacks and near blacks well. This is one of the main complaints about LCD displays from those who are used to a CRT. Blocking a backlight with liquid crystals is quite effective, but it's not as good as not having that light blasting away to begin with. When looking at black measurement numbers, the lower the number, the darker and therefore the better.

These numbers are quite good for black level. By comparison, the typical LCD display runs around .30.

Banding / grayscale

Even at low luminance levels, (60 cd/m2) I could not detect any colored banding on a gray scale gradient. The gray looks very neutral.

Other

Official Specifications

Color Gamut


Uniformity map

Click on image to display larger size



December 2011

Patrick Herold

CHROMiX Technician

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox